Wasn't sure where to post there so I thought it deserved a thread of its own.
This was taken from an Irish Paper - the Irish Examiner
" They once boasted one of the strongest playing rosters in European rugby and were famously labelled the ‘Galacticos’ of Welsh rugby.
With the majority of the Wales squad which won Six Nations Grand Slams in 2008 and 2012 employed by the Ospreys and a glut of world class overseas signings such as All Blacks great Jerry Collins, Marty Holah, Filo Tiatia, Tommy Bowe and Steffan Terblanche also in their squad, the strength in depth at the Liberty Stadium was the envy of many others.
They may not have gone past the quarter-final stage in Europe, but the Swansea-based region won a then record four Guinness PRO12 titles.
Sadly for Ospreys supporters, those days have well and truly been consigned to the history books. Many of the side’s problems today can be traced back to the creation of Welsh rugby’s Professional Rugby Board (PRB) in 2018 which includes members of the Welsh Rugby Union, two independent members, and the chairmen of all four Welsh regions.
The PRB took the decision to cut their budget by close on a million pounds to £6.3m – over a million less than arch-rivals Scarlets. They still boast a host of star players including Wales skipper Alun Wyn Jones and his fellow internationals Justin Tipuric, Adam Beard, Bradley Davies, Dan Lydiate, Nicky Smith and Gareth Anscombe.
But the brutal truth right now is the Ospreys have an unbalanced squad which lacks the strength in depth to compete for silverware. Due to the way the northern hemisphere season is structured, it is the sides with the best international window squads who typically reach the play-offs. But the Ospreys management seem to have ignored this fact and have instead opted to strengthen their starting XV rather than the whole which was typified by the signing of Wales out-half Anscombe whose knee injury suffered in August has ruled him out for the entire season.
When the Ospreys were successful in the past they had a core group of players who were available all year long such as Collins, Hollah, Tiatia, Jason Spice, Nicky Walker and Kahn Fotuali’i. That is no longer the case with not enough high-quality non-Welsh qualified players to steady the ship during the international window.
Many supporters have pointed the finger at Allen Clarke. After all, the buck does stop with the head coach. But the Ospreys’ demise goes a lot deeper than their coaching set-up and Rugby general manager Andrew Millward, who took control in 2016, has big questions to answer.
Since Millward took the reins, the region’s fortunes have plummeted. Millward is the man in charge of hiring and firing coaches while he also has the final say in recruiting players. And it doesn’t seem like he has learnt the lessons of the Ospreys’ recent failures with the Welsh region heavily chasing the signature of Wales and Saracens full-back Liam Williams.
Should he arrive, it will do nothing to improve the depth in their squad given his international responsibilities.
The Ospreys came within 24 hours of going out of existence last season when they were almost forced to merge with bitter rivals the Scarlets.
Their most prominent benefactor Rob Davies swooped in to save the day by taking over the chairmanship and telling the Scarlets and the PRB in no uncertain terms they were there to stay. The start of the Heineken Champions Cup and their opener with Munster at the Liberty on Saturday has come at the worst possible time for the Ospreys with 18 players unavailable due to a combination of a World Cup rest period and injuries.
Unlike in other countries, the majority of Wales’ World Cup stars have been given between four and six weeks off to recuperate from the physical and mental exertions of rugby’s global showpiece which ended with a heartbreaking semi-final defeat to eventual winners South Africa.
Peripheral squad players such as scrum-half Aled Davies and second row Bradley Davies might be reintroduced to face Munster, but they will be without the likes of Wales legend Jones and Tipuric for the opening rounds of Europe which also includes a trip to face an angry Saracens outfit.
The mental fortitude of this Ospreys squad is being seriously tested with Clarke having described their mood as being “at the bottom of the pit” following their embarrassing home defeat at the hands of South African whipping boys Southern Kings last Saturday.
With the region’s very future having been thrown into question earlier this year, doubts persist over their long-term viability. Welsh rugby is scratching its head over how to bridge the funding gap between themselves and their wealthier PRO14 and European rivals.
Rumours abound over the potential of two fully funded Welsh regions and two semi-skimmed versions which would take the form of development teams. This is all conjecture at the moment, but what is certain is that the Ospreys are in a very precarious position on and off the field.
Such speculation has spilled on to the field with Clarke’s side winning just one of their opening six PRO14 fixtures. Given their unavailable players and the toxic atmosphere surrounding the region, it would constitute one of the biggest shocks in the history of European rugby if they were to progress from Pool 4. Munster should be licking their lips at what lies in wait for them."
I have underlined and emboldened some of the more pertinent points in my humble opinion.
Discuss......
That is your call. Personally I would not close down any debate. There are some home truths in what he is saying. Independent journalists are not always truly independent but we should always be prepared to debate and sometimes things with a kernel of truth hurt. It is a bit along the lines of I don't like or agree with everything you say but I defend your right to say it.
I have just been advised this article is by Steffan Thomas who is a freelance reporter who is a prolific poster on Scarlet fever. It strikes me as highly agenda driven. He knows the collapse of the Ospreys means more money for his team of which he is a fanatical supporter. This could easily see a resurrection of the whispering campaign of last year and we have no Peter Owen to fight back. Rob Davies needs to get on top of this before it starts again and look very closely into how the off field PR debacle was allowed to happen or before we know it we will see another whispering campaign from the likes of Holley Scrum V and the Western Mail.
You only need to look back to the Australia game which we won with 2nd and 3rd choice players with a sprinkling of outstanding overseas players, and what we can put out when our first choices are away with TW at the moment, the comment in the newspaper article about the chasing of Liam Williams is exactly the point. We need better 2nd and 3rd choice players in 2 or 3 positions than Sanjay IMO.
That hits the nail bang on the head! I've been saying for years we need squad core of quality NWQ players to be the spine of the team when our Welsh internationals are away. It's not rocket science and anybody with half a brain can see that. The board need to take a long hard look in the mirror and Millward (and the board) needs to be take to account.